Taken from Hilgendorf Responds by Kurt Hilgendorf:
My review of Gerry Nicosia's "Home to War" in the Spring 2004 Veteran offered three main critiques:
1. The book suffers from numerous historical inaccuracies.
2. Through his tone, use of language, and narratives of events, Nicosia positions himself as the enlightened liberal observer who is intellectually superior to the more radical VVAW leadership of the early 1970s. As a result, every VVAW action after Dewey Canyon III, driven by leaders whose sole motivation was dogmatic political ideology, is made to appear ineffective at best and doomed to failure at worst.
3. As a history of a movement, the book focuses far too much on the major individual actors and not enough on the intricacies of building and sustaining an organized effort for social change.... Read More